ctipilot.ch

2026-08-23T1311Z-audit

One pipeline fire, in full · audit run of 2026-08-23 · sub-agent allocation and telemetry, per-iteration verification verdicts and findings, source-list edits, coverage gaps, bridge invocations — and the run's own verification & coverage notes: what was published, what was dropped at the borderline or judged not relevant (and why), single-source carve-outs, and contradictions. Rendered from runs/2026-08-23/2026-08-23T1311Z-audit.md.

Run telemetry

2026-08-23T1311Z-audit audit prompt v3.33 publish ok
30h 58m duration 1 published 1 updates
Claude Fable 5 (claude-fable-5) main agent
G1 Claude Sonnet 5 (claude-sonnet-5)
Items returned
6
Duration
19m 50s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
G2 Claude Sonnet 5 (claude-sonnet-5)
Items returned
1
Duration
9m 17s
Tool calls
20 WebFetch14 WebSearch8 bridge
Cited sources
none
G3 Claude Sonnet 5 (claude-sonnet-5)
Items returned
11
Duration
22m 09s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B1 unknown (unknown)
Items returned
20
Duration
31m 45s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B2 unknown (unknown)
Items returned
20
Duration
21m 42s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B3 unknown (unknown)
Items returned
20
Duration
22m 34s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B4 Claude Sonnet 5 (claude-sonnet-5)
Items returned
20
Duration
8m 22s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B5 unknown (unknown)
Items returned
20
Duration
26m 06s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B6 Claude Sonnet 5 (claude-sonnet-5)
Items returned
20
Duration
14m 14s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none
truth-B7 unknown (unknown)
Items returned
15
Duration
22m 41s
Tool calls
not reported
Cited sources
none

Verification

#? NEEDS_FIXES · Opus 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0 #? CLEAN · Sonnet 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0 #? NEEDS_FIXES · Opus 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0 #? CLEAN · Sonnet 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0 #? CLEAN · Opus 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0 #? NEEDS_FIXES · Sonnet 5 · t=0 e=0 a=0

Deep dive

Sources changed (this run)

Edits this run made to sources/sources.json · promotions, demotions, new candidates, and fetch-method / category / reliability / url corrections (the run record's sources_changed[]). Paginated; 10 per page.

No source-list edits recorded for this run.

Coverage gaps (this run)

Sources this run's brief needed that returned no usable content via any documented recipe. Bridge-recovered or quiet-day sources do NOT appear here. (Distinct from the independent source-accessibility probe at the foot of this section, which probes all active sources regardless of what any run needed.)

No coverage gaps in this run · every source the brief needed returned usable content via its documented recipe.

Verification findings · all iterations

Per-iteration finding detail. Each table is one verifier pass · what was flagged, how the main agent remediated it, and the outcome. Walking the tables top-to-bottom shows the verifier's debugging trail across iterations.

Iteration #? NEEDS_FIXES · 7 findings (truth=0, editorial=0, advisory=0) · Claude Opus 5 · —

F-codeSectionItem · URL/quoteVerifier summaryRemediation · outcome
F1
claim-not-supported
the body and sourcing_note attributed the cve.org record's defaultStatus vocabulary to the cited customer-portal page, which expresses the same fact as state 'Not affected' with per-product justificatreworded body and sourcing_note to the cited page's own vocabulary; the fact itself was confirmed true on both documents
F2
hallucinated-fact
the published/queued split misdescribed the GitLab entry as an error correction; the census is 1 published correction, 5 queued via 4 rows, 4 documented, with GitLab a completeness recoverycorrected the report heading and the run-record sentence to the verifier's census
F3
hallucinated-fact
'cves_seen re-synced for both' — only CVE-2026-18963 had been re-synced; the CVE-2026-19478 record still carried the stale no-exploitation titlere-synced the CVE-2026-19478 record (last_seen 2026-08-24, exploitation status appended to the title) rather than softening the sentence
F4
hallucinated-fact
'7 changes' matched neither the 8 sources_changed[] entries nor the 12 source records actually touchedrestated as 8 entries covering 12 records
F5
hallucinated-fact
'Warning sweep: zero' contradicted the working tree, which carries exactly one WARN — this run's own disclosed runaway durationrestated honestly: Phase 0 ended 0/0/14; the commit carries one warning, this fire's own wall-clock fact, left for the next audit per the self-acknowledgment ba
F6
editorial-advisory
completed preceded this iteration — the exact inversion this run root-causedre-stamped after recording this iteration; final re-stamp at Phase 6 step 0
F7
editorial-advisory
the count-reconciliation row rendered as a near-empty table linereplaced with a footnote under the table

Iteration #? NEEDS_FIXES · 1 finding (truth=0, editorial=0, advisory=0) · Claude Opus 5 · —

F-codeSectionItem · URL/quoteVerifier summaryRemediation · outcome
F14
quantifier-without-source
the clock-inversion count of 98/153 undercounted by three — the confirmation pass recounted with the report's own criterion and found 101, the delta being the three 2026-07-14 fires whose ended_at valcorrected to 101 of 153 in the report (Verdict + finding 1), the run record, the CHANGELOG, the cti-run.md prompt text and the check_run.py comment; regenerated

Iteration #? CLEAN · 1 finding (truth=0, editorial=0, advisory=0) · Claude Opus 5 · —

F-codeSectionItem · URL/quoteVerifier summaryRemediation · outcome
F14
editorial-advisory
a second new comment line still carried the superseded 98 figure (and in that sentence the accurate suppressed count is the ~50 the store report prints)comment reworded; non-blocking, outside the four-file scope, swept before commit

Iteration #? NEEDS_FIXES cap-breach · 1 finding (truth=0, editorial=0, advisory=0) · Claude Sonnet 5 · —

F-codeSectionItem · URL/quoteVerifier summaryRemediation · outcome
F9
lockstep-drift
the alt verifier drifted one token from the primary (its truth-check 1 still read v3.32 where the primary read v3.33) — the post-merge renumber pass edited the primary after the alt had been regenerattoken corrected and byte-identity below the H1 re-proven programmatically; all five other post-merge deltas (duplicate drop, cves_seen re-syncs, v3.33 renumberi

Verification & coverage notes

The run record's narrative body, verbatim. This is where the run accounts for its own judgement calls — every borderline drop and judged-not-relevant item with its reason, dedup decisions, single-source items and their carve-outs, contradictions, and per-source coverage gaps — so nothing the run considered disappears silently.

Verification & coverage notesrun record body

2026-08-23T1311Z-audit · audit · Fable 5 · window 335.9 h · 1 entry published

Verification & coverage notes

Audit window 2026-08-09T13:15:57Z → 2026-08-23T13:11:00Z (335.9 h — double width because no audit fired on 2026-08-16; inside the 21-day cap, so nothing truncated). 135 entries across 16 run records; seven truth-pass batches covered every window entry exactly once (no batch abandoned), and all three coverage re-sweeps returned inside their caps. Headline: 112/135 clean · 13 imprecisions · 10 factual errors; one factual error corrected by a published update entry (Keycloak), five queued on the coverage backlog via four rows with full ground truth, four documented without a repair (reasons in the report). Full findings: docs/audits/2026-08-23-weekly-quality-audit.md.

Wall-clock disclosure: the container was suspended overnight between the sub-agent wave (all back by 13:45Z, 23 Aug) and main-agent synthesis (resumed 08:50Z, 24 Aug) — elapsed ≈ 20 h, active work ≈ 2.5 h. Four fires reached main mid-audit: the 2026-08-23T2311Z and 2026-08-24T0110Z weeklies, plus — decisively — the 2026-08-21T0410Z and 2026-08-22T0410Z intel fires, which had run on schedule but sat unpromoted on their feature branch for ~2 days (see the report's systemic finding 5 and the new promotion-latency watch item). origin/main was re-merged and every artifact re-checked: the weekly independently found the same Keycloak defect (its backlog row is struck by this fire's correction entry), the 08-22 fire had already published both the GitLab exploitation update and SPIP (this fire's GitLab duplicate dropped, its SPIP backlog row struck), and the two late fires' ~17 in-window entries were NOT in this audit's Phase 0 snapshot — auditing them is the next fire's first duty.

Model self-identification: the main agent's harness line reads Fable 5 (claude-fable-5). Several sub-agent returns arrived through completion summaries that did not preserve the **Model:** line — those records carry unknown rather than an inferred value; the ones that reported are recorded verbatim (B4/B6/G2 from return headers; G1/G3 from their findings-YAML model lines: all Sonnet 5).

Operator directives (2026-08-24, mid-run, implemented this commit): trafilatura is the standard capture layer (extract subcommand; 18/20 test hosts need no reader — evidence in work/2026-08-23T1311Z-audit/trafilatura-rollout.md); push notifications only for critical-class vulnerabilities and pipeline breakage; permission-free memory writes plus repo-persisted memory (symlink verified live). Per that notification policy, this audit ends with no operator notification: nothing in the window is a currently-unmitigated critical-class exposure and the pipeline is functioning.

Systemic summary (full detail in the report): the run-clock falsification (101/153 records; fixed in v3.33 + a run-clock gate FAIL); verifier convergence 3/16 confirmed CLEAN with the iteration-2 early exit recurring (recommendation 4 proposes a scoped re-check); the OT/ICS dark surface diagnosed per source — one dark (claroty-team82), two recipes fixed, one still broken (sans-ics); actions[] discipline recovered (0.80/entry, 42.3 % actionless, zero generic on hand review); 16/16 publish_status ok; cadence gaps self-healed with verified backfill.

Recovered coverage: Keycloak CVE-2026-18963 product-state correction published (2026-08-24/cve-2026-18963-keycloak-no-red-hat-product-unfixed). A second recovery — the GitLab CVE-2026-19478 exploitation-status update — was composed and fully verified by this fire, then dropped at the Phase 6 sync as a duplicate: the late-promoting 2026-08-22T0410Z-intel fire had independently published the same delta (2026-08-22/cve-2026-19478-gitlab-honeypot-exploitation-confirmed), which reached main only mid-audit. The dedup discipline governs; the gap this audit identified was real when identified and had already been closed by a fire whose record this audit could not see at Phase 0. state/cves_seen.json was re-synced for that CVE (exploited status) because the 08-22 fire had left the index stale. Nine coverage items queued on state/coverage_backlog.md with discovery traces (Claroty Copeland + Danfoss, SPIP CVE-2026-77647 — the next fire's first item —, GreenPlasma, CNCMachineRMS, Kudelski DPRK-IT-worker, Bloctel/DGCCRF, plus two contingent AI items pending dedup against the W34 weekly).

Watch items: actions-density CLOSED (recovered); dark-OT CLOSED as a class (successor: sans-ics recipe); Bloctel RESOLVED (queued for publication); Afpa, Berlin, Zurich unchanged-open; two NEW (Claroty rows' identifier-mapping rigor; trafilatura rollout holds).

Coverage gaps: none — every truth batch completed and every re-sweep returned.

← Operations dashboard · day page 2026-08-23 · run-record contract: docs/pipeline.md